Shared from #onpoli ~ Have you heard of Ontario Proud or Canada Proud?
Tuesday, September 10, 2019
Hello, #onpoli people,
We’re back from our summer hibernation with our first episode of Season 3! This fall, we’re all about the federal election.
We are kicking things off with a look at a new player in the Canadian election landscape: social media-savvy third-party advocacy groups such as Ontario Proud or Canada Proud. Haven’t heard of them? Don’t worry: we’ve got you covered.
Third-party advocacy groups are edgy, provocative, and — depending on whom you ask — downright offensive. They exist on both the left and right. They also have a massive online footprint. Ontario Proud, for example, has garnered more engagement on Facebook than some of Canada’s largest news outlets.
Research shows that more than half of Canadians get their news from social media.1 “It’s hard to compete from a straight news perspective,” says Kaleigh Rogers, a senior CBC reporter covering disinformation. “Which one is going to draw your attention more?” she asks, referring to the act of scrolling through posts on a Facebook or Twitter timeline. “The one that makes you feel really angry or really scared…or the one that is just kind of neutral?”
Whether or not groups like Ontario Proud have played a role, Steve Paikin notes in this episode that “there’s a lot less civilized dialogue among the different sides in our political debates.”
Toxin to democracy, or cure for apathy?
Steve spoke with Jeff Ballingall, founder of Ontario Proud and now Canada Proud, in this episode. At one point, Steve asks him: “How much [do] you think you have contributed to that state of affairs?”
“I think what's more dangerous is apathy,” says Ballingall. “I think that’s way worse. I’d rather have people fighting and coming to conclusions and having ideas and caring than not.”
"We need more people paying attention to politics,” he says. “And if we’re a bit shocking and if we’re a bit abrasive and if we’re a little bit loud, so be it. But we’re a part of the political dialogue.”
Steve Paikin and Ontario Proud founder Jeff Ballingall ready to record.
So do third-party advocacy groups really inject more anger and fear into the electorate, or have they simply figured out how to play the internet game well, and managed to bring more people into the national conversation in the process?
Steve wasn’t so sure. He pushed back on Ballingall’s statement that groups like Ontario Proud are an effective remedy to apathy.
“When I was a kid, more people hung out in the middle,” says Steve, “and anywhere from 80 to 90 per cent of those people used to show up and vote in elections. And now people have sort of retreated to their respective corners in this boxing ring, and half to 60 per cent of people are showing up for elections.
“You could make the argument that people are a lot more apathetic today because people like you have poisoned the well so much," Steve says. "I’m not saying it; I’m saying that argument is there. Respond if you would.”
You can listen to Ballingall’s response and the full episode here.
And, as always, please write in with any of your queries or comments about the episode. What do you think of these new online third-party groups? Email us at firstname.lastname@example.org.
How we do what we do
TVO is funded as a public agency by the government of Ontario. But when we do something new, like the #onpoli podcast and this newsletter, we often rely on generous donors like you to get it off the ground.
If you like what we're doing with #onpoli, please make a donation to keep it going. We'd like to feature the donors who make our work possible on future episodes of the podcast. So, if you make a donation, please write to us and let us know what you like about #onpoli at email@example.com.
1. “Canadians get news from social media but don’t trust it: poll,” Radio Canada International, April 2019